Overtime Pay After Taxes: What You Actually Keep (2026)

Overtime pay is taxed the same way as regular wages — but because it adds to your total annual income, it is effectively taxed at your highest (marginal) federal rate. Understanding what fraction of overtime gross you actually keep helps you plan cash flow and make informed decisions about taking extra hours.

How Overtime Works Under the FLSA

The Fair Labor Standards Act requires that eligible employees receive at least 1.5 times their regular rate of pay for hours worked beyond 40 in a workweek. For an employee earning $75,000 per year (approximately $36/hour based on 2,080 annual hours), the overtime rate is approximately $54/hour. Each overtime hour earns significantly more before tax — but withholding means the after-tax gain per overtime hour is less than 1.5x the regular after-tax hourly rate.

Engine-Derived Example: Base vs. Base Plus Overtime

For a single filer in Texas with a base salary of $75,000, the engine estimates annual take-home of $61,593. Adding approximately $7,500 in overtime earnings brings total annual income to $82,500, producing estimated take-home of $66,869. The additional gross of $7,500 yields a net increase of approximately $5,276 — an effective keep rate of about 70.3% on the overtime gross in this no-income-tax state.

Why the Paycheck Withholding Looks Inflated

When overtime is included in a regular paycheck, payroll annualizes the gross for that period to determine withholding. A check that includes significant overtime appears, to the payroll system, as though your annual salary is much higher than it actually is — triggering a higher withholding rate for that period. This is not a permanent change to your withholding; it reflects the annualization method. If you work overtime sporadically, you may see inconsistent withholding period-to-period that reconciles over the year.

Federal Marginal Rate on Overtime

Whether overtime income crosses you into a higher federal bracket depends on your total annual earnings. For many full-time workers, moderate overtime stays within the same bracket as their base salary. Significant amounts of overtime — especially for workers already near the top of a bracket — can push some income into the next higher rate. Use the calculator to model your base salary and your base plus expected overtime to see the annual take-home difference and implied marginal rate on the additional income.

State Taxes on Overtime

Most states tax overtime as regular income under their standard schedules — no special rate. No-income-tax states (Texas, Florida, Washington, and others) add zero state withholding on overtime, making overtime income worth more in those states. In California or New York, state income tax adds a further reduction to overtime net pay beyond the federal and FICA withholding.

FICA on Overtime

Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%) apply to all overtime wages just as they do to regular pay. Medicare applies to all wages with no ceiling. Social Security stops once year-to-date wages reach the annual wage base — which benefits high earners or those who work large amounts of overtime. The Additional Medicare Tax (0.9%) applies to wages above $200,000 for single filers.

Planning: Reduce the Tax Bite With 401(k) Contributions

If your overtime income is pushing you into a higher bracket, consider temporarily increasing your traditional 401(k) contribution rate during periods of heavy overtime. Pre-tax 401(k) contributions reduce federal taxable wages, which can bring your effective annualized income for that period back into a lower bracket and reduce per-paycheck withholding. The contribution also grows tax-deferred, turning the overtime premium into long-term savings.

Compare your take-home with and without overtime income.

Open the calculator →

Frequently Asked Questions

Is overtime taxed at a higher rate than regular pay?

No. Overtime wages are ordinary wage income and taxed at your marginal federal income tax rate — the same rate as your regular pay at that income level. There is no special overtime tax rate. However, because overtime adds to your annual income, a larger portion of your total earnings may fall into a higher federal bracket than your base salary alone would reach.

Why does the withholding on overtime paychecks look so large?

Payroll software annualizes your period gross pay to determine withholding. When overtime raises your paycheck gross significantly above the normal amount, the system sees a higher annualized income for that period and withholds at a higher rate. Over a full year, total withholding still tracks your actual earnings — but any single paycheck with heavy overtime can look disproportionately withheld.

At 1.5x overtime, how much of the extra pay do I actually keep?

Most full-time workers keep approximately 60%–70% of gross overtime income as net pay after federal income tax withholding at their marginal rate, plus Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%). Workers in higher brackets keep less; those in lower brackets keep more. State income tax further reduces the net in states with income tax.

Does overtime count toward the Social Security wage base?

Yes. Overtime pay is included in Social Security wages and counts toward the annual wage base cap. Once your total wages — including overtime — exceed the annual wage base, Social Security withholding stops on additional earnings for the rest of the year. High earners who regularly work overtime early in the year often hit the cap before year-end.

Figures and methods are based on official-source data encoded in the calculator. Not tax advice. Review the methodology and consult a qualified professional for your situation.